My Links

Bloggernacle Links

  • Mormon Archipelago
  • Mormon Blogs
  • LDSelect
  • LDS Blogs

Article Categories

Post Categories

Archives

Other LDS Blogs

Our Individual Blogs

Holiday Smackdown: Christmas vs Easter

By: The Baron

I've always wondered why--pagan and secular influences aside--Christmas turned out to be the major Christian holiday of the year rather than Easter.

What does Easter represent?  The sacrifice, Atonement, and subsequent resurrection of the Savior--a vital part of the Plan of Salvation, and of mankind's eternal progression.  Basically, every single reason we have to worship the Savior ties into the events represented by Easter.

What does Christmas represent?  Well...the birth of the Savior.

But, see, Jesus Christ's birth didn't actually *do* anything, except set in motion His earthly life that would culminate in the events of Easter.  Mankind was not better off in any significant way the day after Mary gave birth than the day before--his presence in the world as an infant did not provide any tangible (or spiritual) blessing to anyone alive or dead at the time, except for perhaps Mary and Joseph themselves. 

Basically, any blessing derived from the Savior's birth can be summed up in one word: hope.

Mankind, due to the Savior's birth, had 'hope' that they could be saved from sin and that they can return to their Heavenly Father's presence.  Without minimizing the value of hope and optimism in many people's lives, we should note, by definition, 'hope'  basically means everyone still has just as crummy a life now as they always had, but now at least they have a reason to look forward to things possibly becoming better sometime in the future.  And that 'sometime in the future', of course, was Easter.

It seems illogical, then, that Christmas would become, even for Christians, a more significant holiday than Easter, because 'Christmas' in essence represents only the hope that 'Easter' will soon be coming.  And without Easter (the Atonement and resurrection), Christmas (the Savior's birth) would mean nothing in the end.

Is there a reason for this?  I think fundamentally, Christmas is Christmas because people want and need a 'happy' holiday, full of the proverbial 'Christmas cheer'.  People want a holiday focused on family...and what better symbol of family and happiness than the birth of a baby (Christ-child or not...)?

Fundamentally, I think people subconsciously don't like to "celebrate" a holiday where the key event was a righteous man getting scourged and crucified, even if it has more significance to their eternal beliefs (and a "happy ending" through the resurrection).  Even though, logically, Easter should be dearer to the hearts of Christians, perhaps most people still prefer an observance of lesser significance which doesn't have the baggage of death and suffering hiding right behind it.

Not to be a holiday spoilsport, though, I still prefer Easter to Christmas from a religious perspective.  (Holidays off from work, on the other hand...)  Especially since the purpose of Christmas was simply to point the way to Easter in the first place...

Print | posted on Thursday, December 20, 2007 9:45 AM | Filed Under [ The Baron ]

Comments:

#1: Eric Nielson

I have had similar thoughts as well. In a way I think it might be a good thing. Much along the lines of Starfoxys recent post on Christmas. Easter allows us a more simple holiday to focus on more important things.
12/20/2007 3:11 PM

#2: Ray

I like the idea of a simpler, purer Easter celebration. Now we just need to take Elmer Fudd's advice and "kill the wabbit!"
12/20/2007 4:31 PM

#3: Eric Nielson

Metaphorically speaking, I'm sure.
12/21/2007 9:37 AM

#4: Stady Canton

I think you and my five year old are on the same wavelength as far as Easter goes, Baron.

To a world that believes in original sin a child born "free" from that sin would be quite significant.
12/22/2007 11:57 PM

#5: Tanya

I would have to say that there is also that factor that we cannot relate to the joy of resurrections. It is beyond our capacity to comprehend that kind of joy. We do understand the sorrow of death, and even in a church where we focus on the entire aspect of the atonement, from the events in the garden, to the death on the cross and he ultimate triumph over death, it is a more solemn occasion. I think just the nature of the idea that this marvelous man, our brother would do such a thing is more thought provoking in the long run. I love the idea of Easter, and the worship of the day. It is a day to remember what He did for us.

Christmas on the other had is something most people can relate too. The joy of a newborn baby is one of the most incredible moments experienced. As a mother there is nothing like giving birth to a wanted and loved child, as a nurse attending delivery I am always amazed at the miracle of life, and those who are childless that then are allowed the gift to hold a baby given to them would have the same kind of joy and gratitude. Birth is a joyous occasion, and what is more joyous than the birth of the saviour. I believe that is why we celebrate Christmas in the manner that we do, with joy, and as mentioned above, HOPE. It lifts the spirit and soul because we can relate to it.

I would suspect when all is said and done, Easter will become the joy of our hearts, as we then can relate to the gift of the resurrections and being reunited with loved ones gone before us.

(Besides, who can resist the Angels singing to the shepherds, there was joy in the heavens as well.)
1/4/2008 9:45 AM

Post Comment:

Name  
Email
Url
Comment   
Please add 1 and 7 and type the answer here:

Powered by: